Right. But now that whole scene has me wondering.... how would Richard know what already belonged to Locke? Okay, the sand represents the island, yeah yeah I get it.... but technically the compass isn't Locke's (unless it's meant to be a more abstract representation of finding his way to the island, and not needing a compass after a few weeks being there, etc.). And I know that point's been discussed and pummeled. But what else would Richard know that John owns? How is Richard the expert here?