Charlotte Should not be born yet.

[Lyricc96]

There would have been no other point for showing us that little girl! After Daniels rambling about Charlotte dying it only makes sense (if thats possible) for it to be Charlotte!

[Jugdish]

Time jumping may have been a factor. Good point, but I guess it would depend on how she left??? I still think that a fake passport may have been her only link to her birth though.

I just don't believe they sent little Charlotte down to turn the donkey wheel

[Lyricc96]

I agree, but we may not know of all the different ways people get off the island. I think it will be important to know why she left first.

[opgelost]

Time jumping may have been a factor. Good point, but I guess it would depend on how she left??? I still think that a fake passport may have been her only link to her birth though.

I just don't believe they sent little Charlotte down to turn the donkey wheel

That's the only way to skip ten years of your life.

[Jugdish]

Charlotte stated that she grew up on the Island, in the DHARMA Initiative, though she and her mother had to leave while she was still quite young. Her father did not leave with them. At some point while she was on the island, she had an encounter with a "crazy" man (who she later came to believe was Daniel Faraday) who told her that she should never come back to the island or else she would die. After they settled in England, Charlotte says that whenever she would ask her mother about the island, her mother would insist that it was not real, and that she had imagined it

[Jugdish]

Time jumping may have been a factor. Good point, but I guess it would depend on how she left??? I still think that a fake passport may have been her only link to her birth though.

I just don't believe they sent little Charlotte down to turn the donkey wheel

That's the only way to skip ten years of your life.

It is the only way that we know of so far.

[hyperform]

What if Charlotte's mom turned the wheel to leave the island with young Charlotte in tow, that would explain the ten year discrepancy and would explain why she not only knew what the orchid really was, and why she knew where the well lead to.

[opgelost]

I would like to know when Charlotte's body is.
When Jin flashed from when Montand lost his arm to when Rousseau shot Robert,
Montands arm was still there, in decay, but still there.

Now they flash from a period when the well is there, but the orchid not yet
to a time when the statue is there to a time when the well is there, but closed.
And Charlotte's body is gone. Did she die in the first period or in the statueperiod?
In what time is her body and who is going to find it or how does it disappear?

[Lyricc96]

What if Charlotte's mom turned the wheel to leave the island with young Charlotte in tow, that would explain the ten year discrepancy and would explain why she not only knew what the orchid really was, and why she knew where the well lead to.


TRUE!!!

[Lyricc96]

I would like to know when Charlotte's body is.
When Jin flashed from when Montand lost his arm to when Rousseau shot Robert,
Montands arm was still there, in decay, but still there.

Now they flash from a period when the well is there, but the orchid not yet
to a time when the statue is there to a time when the well is there, but closed.
And Charlotte's body is gone. Did she die in the first period or in the statueperiod?
In what time is her body and who is going to find it or how does it disappear?

Thats a good point! I'm not sure if it was because they went back in time instead of forward. She is only 5 where they are now. If they had of shifted time into the future, her body should have still been there.

[opgelost]

I supposed they went forward in time, because the well was closed with earth.
To build a well you start digging and build the wall later or do you first build
the wall and than dig inside of it? I never digged a well.

[this is some crazy stuff]

I would like to know when Charlotte's body is.
When Jin flashed from when Montand lost his arm to when Rousseau shot Robert,
Montands arm was still there, in decay, but still there.

Now they flash from a period when the well is there, but the orchid not yet
to a time when the statue is there to a time when the well is there, but closed.
And Charlotte's body is gone. Did she die in the first period or in the statueperiod?
In what time is her body and who is going to find it or how does it disappear?

She died right before the flash that made the Losties see the statue. So this we can assume is somewhere near present time.  So when the island shifted back in time her body was not there.   I guess that is the only way to explain it.

[JBRam]

I supposed they went forward in time, because the well was closed with earth.
To build a well you start digging and build the wall later or do you first build
the wall and than dig inside of it? I never digged a well.

I think you dig first. I mean, you can't really build a wall underground if it's still covered with dirt.

[Survivor815]

Last year Ben stated that Charlotte's birthday was July 2, 1979. How is she alive on the island in 1974 when Daniel sees her??

Did Ben lie or is it a mistake by the producers?

I thought the same thing last night and it confused the hell out of me!!!     But Lost will do that to ya! lol

[lostieloo]

Could it have been that other elusive redhead Annie?