Congrats on your pool win, Shakey!
I have always thought that to do a real "All-Stars", it almost has to be all the winners, and them only. They don't stand a snowball's chance in an All-Star game with people who didn't win -- it's a no-brainer to vote them out because they already got a million.
I think I read somewhere that they tried to do this, but Brian from Thailand refused to play because he wanted more money than they were willing to pay him or something. That is one of only two seasons that I didn't watch, but from what I understand, he is a real horse's patoot. And of course, Hatch couldn't play because he's still in jail, isn't he? And now Ethan's getting treatments for Hodgekins' lymphoma...
Another good one might be composed of contestants that fans thought should've won, but didn't. They might not necessarily be second-place or third-place, or whatever. No eye-candy, though, only real "players." I still can't believe Amber winning the first All-Stars when she should never have been there in the first place -- when they announced that cast, I was like "Who? Who's she?" Ugh.