I THOUGHT NADIA WAS ALREADY DEAD

[solost]

In season 1 when Rousseau captures Sayid, she finds the picture of Nadia that Sayid had on him. She asks who the girl in the picture is. Sayid says it's my girl friend, she is dead because of me. I killed her. Am I misunderstanding some thing here? Wasn't the reason Sayid was on 815 was so he could get to L.A. to find Nadia? The CIA agent said they knew where she was and they would tell him after he helped them? Now we see Sayid at Nadia's funeral. WHATS UP WITH THIS?

[jugdish]

He lied to Danielle for sympathy. Got off the island found Nadia and married her. She was then killed.

[solost]

He lied to Danielle for sympathy. Got off the island found Nadia and married her. She was then killed.

YO.......TANKS!!!

[T Mack]

He thought she was dead, but wasn't.  Later found out she was hiding out in L.A. from the CIA officer in Australia.

[LostAndSeek]

Right, but he found that out before leaving on 815.

[LostinLock]

Yeah, he was using sympathy .... Plus he was well trained

[Tigre]

But why was she murdered???

[solost]

But why was she murdered???

I think Ben killed Nadia. What does he always say "I find out what a person is emotionally invested in and I exploit it". Sayid is invested in Nadia, Ben needs a HIT MAN, Ben kills Nadia and makes Sayid think it was a Widmore bad guy. What do you think about that? 

[Gizmogrl83]

But why was she murdered???

I think Ben killed Nadia. What does he always say "I find out what a person is emotionally invested in and I exploit it". Sayid is invested in Nadia, Ben needs a HIT MAN, Ben kills Nadia and makes Sayid think it was a Widmore bad guy. What do you think about that? 

I have thought about this many times, but as much as Ben lies and cheats his way towards whatever his goal is I just for some reason don't see him as the total bad guy.  I am just naiive though 

[solost]

But why was she murdered???

I think Ben killed Nadia. What does he always say "I find out what a person is emotionally invested in and I exploit it". Sayid is invested in Nadia, Ben needs a HIT MAN, Ben kills Nadia and makes Sayid think it was a Widmore bad guy. What do you think about that? 

I have thought about this many times, but as much as Ben lies and cheats his way towards whatever his goal is I just for some reason don't see him as the total bad guy.  I am just naiive though 

Your not being naive. Ben doesn't have any solders/hit man left. Tom is dead Picket is dead Ryan is dead and most of Ryan's people are dead. Even Isabell is dead. I just think he needs someone to do his killing for him. Don't forget the RULES have changed.

[T Mack]

He thought she was dead, but wasn't.  Later found out she was hiding out in L.A. from the CIA officer in Australia.

Just one day earlier.  But yes correct.

[laklost]

The saddest thing is that I think we lost the Nadia/Sayid reunion story.  I bet that fell on the floor when we lost two eps this season. 

[solost]

The saddest thing is that I think we lost the Nadia/Sayid reunion story.  I bet that fell on the floor when we lost two eps this season. 

I hope not.

[LostAndSeek]

I kinda think it was a victim of the writers' strike as well. Consider the original word on this epi was that it was titled "Bakir" and Sayid centric. Methinks two epis were condensed to one.

[laklost]

I kinda think it was a victim of the writers' strike as well. Consider the original word on this epi was that it was titled "Bakir" and Sayid centric. Methinks two epis were condensed to one.

I can't believe we lost this.  I have been waiting for the moment Sayid saw her agaain, and to think all we got was, "I found her, married her, and she died" just stinks.