So Aaron IS one of the Oceanic Six

[Gizmogrl83]

So all of us who can't wait to actually WATCH the show got fooled.  It's okay guys, at least we know some stuff that the others don't know.  All I know is it made me mad.  I don't want Jin to die, he is honorable.

[Asmodean]

He might not be.
He could have, for one reason or another, been left on the island.

Time will tell.

[JBRam]

Sun's tears were too real for him to be just left behind.

[Asmodean]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

[JBRam]

Possibly.

[laklost]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

I still stay no one would tolerate an empty grave for a living loved one.  No way.

[PrincessLeia]

I still don't believe Aaron is the 6th.

They confirmed it in the podcast.

[Asmodean]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

I still stay no one would tolerate an empty grave for a living loved one.  No way.

If it's the 'secret' and it will save lives...

[laklost]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

I still stay no one would tolerate an empty grave for a living loved one.  No way.

If it's the 'secret' and it will save lives...

Nope.  Not with a new baby.  No.  No.  No.

(IMHO )                                                                                                                             

[Asmodean]

I gots a feeling it was neither of their choices.

I'd sacrifice myself though for any member of my family.

[laklost]

I gots a feeling it was neither of their choices.

I'd sacrifice myself though for any member of my family.

Right - you are the noble type.  But, for me,  if I knew Jim were alive on this earth, I would not sit at his grave and weep.  Death is too powerful, but life is even more so.

[Optimus J]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

I still stay no one would tolerate an empty grave for a living loved one.  No way.

Yup, To have the grave as a stage, OK. To talk to Jin through the grave, too much for me. If Sun and Hugo go talk to the empty grave, then Jin is gone for good.

[JBRam]

If she knew she'd never see him again, they'd be the same as if he were dead.

I still stay no one would tolerate an empty grave for a living loved one.  No way.

Yup, To have the grave as a stage, OK. To talk to Jin through the grave, too much for me. If Sun and Hugo go talk to the empty grave, then Jin is gone for good.

Completely agree. If she wanted to talk to Jin, she wouldn't go to a grave if he's alive. The grave is a marker. She'd probably talk to something that reminds her of him personally, rather than a cold stone.

See the show for what it is, not what we want it to be.

[jugdish]

You would if you were covering up the fact that he is still alive. Hurley said it so matter of factly, "time to go" that it appeared that is planned to make a public showing of the fact.

If she wanted to keep it  a secret that he is alive, she would have to make apparances at his grave. Taking the new baby there would throw people off the track.

[LostAndSeek]

I agree. I think Jin's well being is a 50-50 shot at this point.