Now, I'm trying to recall... when has Smokey ever appeared during "whispers"? Now, please, don't jump in my crap if I'm wrong here, my brain isn't what it used to be, but I can only recall Smokey (and by Smokey, I mean the true from of Smokey, not these apparitions of other people that we're calling Smokey, this hasn't been confirmed) appearing to that strange mechanical sound, and to that sound only. Now, like I said, my brain isn't what it used to be, so if the true Smoke monster has appeared during whispers, just let me know which episode it was and I'll happily retract my previous statement. That is, of course, unless I watch the stated episode and don't find Smokey appearing to "whispers"... then I'm coming back with a vengeance!!!