A Man on Their Boat

[joshzam]

When the cats are away, the mice will play.

Regina and George Minkowski are in the middle of a torrid sexual encounter when Miles calls. That's why he can't come to the phone. And that's why she is in such a rush to hang up 

[laklost]

When the cats are away, the mice will play.

Regina and George Minkowski are in the middle of a torrid sexual encounter when Miles calls. Thanks why he can't come to the phone. And that's why she is in such a rush to hang up 

They're the only one within 100 miles then...

[jugdish]

When the cats are away, the mice will play.

Regina and George Minkowski are in the middle of a torrid sexual encounter when Miles calls. Thanks why he can't come to the phone. And that's why she is in such a rush to hang up 

THis is the most logical theory that I have heard in a long time.

[jugdish]

When the cats are away, the mice will play.

Regina and George Minkowski are in the middle of a torrid sexual encounter when Miles calls. Thanks why he can't come to the phone. And that's why she is in such a rush to hang up  

THis is the most logical theory that I have heard in a long time.

[DaveDargo]

Could Penny Widmore be the "man" on the boat?  Only Ben knew about the Looking Glass.  He was in contact with Bonnie and the other wifey and when Charlie switched the light off she just happened to be contacting them.  Penny gives info to Bonnie and friend and they tell Ben.

Of course this assumes that they switched the blocking off to be able to get the info from Penny so maybe she was in contact with the flame until the sky went purple/the flame blew up?  Obviously Penny didn't know what was happening on the island, after the sky went purple/flame blew up, so was trying to contact the Looking Glass to find out what the dealio was.

Of course Desmond could be part of this too, or not even know he is, in that if they do stumble across a lostie they're looking for Desmond (e.g. when Naomi landed on the island and when Penny made contact with Charlie in the looking glass.

Or maybe I should just get back to work!

[bubbles]

Here is my theory on this, just to throw it out there.  I dont think it has been posted yet, but if it has, my apologies.

What if, as some have said, the "man" on the boat isn't a man but a woman?  Maybe it is Ben's girlfriend from the flashbacks?  Annie?  She is going to have to make it back into the story somehow, at least I assume she will.  And wouldn't it be just like Lost to throw us all off by saying "man"?  Not to mention throwing Charlotte off, in the event that she is once again able to communicate with her boat crew.

Just something that popped into my head...

[Ladybug]

i think it's very possible it's a woman.  i think ben's use of the word "man" just meant he had SOMEONE on the boat.

[bubbles]

i think it's very possible it's a woman.  i think ben's use of the word "man" just meant he had SOMEONE on the boat.

Agreed.  What do you think about it maybe being Annie?

[lostfan777]

It COULD be a woman......or a man.....
It COULD be Annie.....or someone we haven't met yet.....or someone we already know....
Maybe Ben got all his info about Charlotte the same way he got everyone else's histories.....or maybe he knows Charlotte personally.....
Maybe Ben is...... lying  ......about having someone on the boat!

My point is, not enough data.  We haven't been told much about Ben yet and we'll know more.......when they decide to tell us!  Until then, we can only guess, but the good news is that if we keep guessing we're bound to be right about something! 

[PrincessLeia]

When the cats are away, the mice will play.

Regina and George Minkowski are in the middle of a torrid sexual encounter when Miles calls. That's why he can't come to the phone. And that's why she is in such a rush to hang up 

THIS WAS AWESOME!  Oh wait...not that.....THIS-

I wonder if the supply crates are being dropped on The Island the same way that the polar bear was dropped in Tunisia. The same way that Jacob's cabin was dropped from one end of a field to the other. The same way that Walt was dropped in front of Shannon in the rain. The same way Bunny 15 was dropped on the top shelf...

Seriously- I'm so on board with this.

[PrincessLeia]

It COULD be a woman......or a man.....
It COULD be Annie.....or someone we haven't met yet.....or someone we already know....
Maybe Ben got all his info about Charlotte the same way he got everyone else's histories.....or maybe he knows Charlotte personally.....
Maybe Ben is...... lying  ......about having someone on the boat!

My point is, not enough data.  We haven't been told much about Ben yet and we'll know more.......when they decide to tell us!  Until then, we can only guess, but the good news is that if we keep guessing we're bound to be right about something! 

Party pooper.

[laklost]

It COULD be a woman......or a man.....
It COULD be Annie.....or someone we haven't met yet.....or someone we already know....
Maybe Ben got all his info about Charlotte the same way he got everyone else's histories.....or maybe he knows Charlotte personally.....
Maybe Ben is...... lying  ......about having someone on the boat!

My point is, not enough data.  We haven't been told much about Ben yet and we'll know more.......when they decide to tell us!  Until then, we can only guess, but the good news is that if we keep guessing we're bound to be right about something! 

Party pooper.

And if we keep guessing, our personal post counts will soar to the heavens! 

[lostfan777]

It COULD be a woman......or a man.....
It COULD be Annie.....or someone we haven't met yet.....or someone we already know....
Maybe Ben got all his info about Charlotte the same way he got everyone else's histories.....or maybe he knows Charlotte personally.....
Maybe Ben is...... lying  ......about having someone on the boat!

My point is, not enough data.  We haven't been told much about Ben yet and we'll know more.......when they decide to tell us!  Until then, we can only guess, but the good news is that if we keep guessing we're bound to be right about something! 

Party pooper.

And if we keep guessing, our personal post counts will soar to the heavens! 

Is there some sort of prize for building up our post counts?  I'm just waiting for the day I can get out of this horrible red shirt! 

[laklost]

It COULD be a woman......or a man.....
It COULD be Annie.....or someone we haven't met yet.....or someone we already know....
Maybe Ben got all his info about Charlotte the same way he got everyone else's histories.....or maybe he knows Charlotte personally.....
Maybe Ben is...... lying  ......about having someone on the boat!

My point is, not enough data.  We haven't been told much about Ben yet and we'll know more.......when they decide to tell us!  Until then, we can only guess, but the good news is that if we keep guessing we're bound to be right about something! 

Party pooper.

And if we keep guessing, our personal post counts will soar to the heavens! 

Is there some sort of prize for building up our post counts?  I'm just waiting for the day I can get out of this horrible red shirt! 

The red shirt is 1,000 times better than the workman jumpsuit.  You've just got 190 to get to Survivor.  And apparently the Survivors wear anything they want to - a Hurley tie-dye, for instance.

[Lion of Atreides]

I don't think Annie's on the boat.  My guess is she took over Vicki's job on The Love Boat.