We Both Know Your Father

[ChrisB4290]

i thought that this was mentioned in a previous episode? im not sure if im alone.

[airdudei]

Ben did not have Alex with Danielle. No evidence of this and everything we know contracdicts this. Either Ben is a surrogate father, or Alex is not Danielles.

How does everything we know contradict this? Alex's name is still Alex. That means Ben didn't just steal Alex from Danielle. As far as I know, Ben knocked her up. It sure seemed to me that he's the real father and until they say so otherwise, all signs point that way to me.

You could not be more off base with this post. What JB said above are the facts. Other than having people call him dad to Alex, every piece of evidence points to Ben not being her biological father.

WHAT EVIDENCE? PROVE IT? I don't have to prove that Ben is not Alex's father. That is what everyone on this site is trying to do. They're SPECULATING that Ben stole Alex and that he lied to her about being her father. Where do you guys get this information from?? Your imagination. I'm being reasonable.

They said Alex's father was Ben. Thats all the evidence I need.

[airdudei]

Ben did not have Alex with Danielle. No evidence of this and everything we know contracdicts this. Either Ben is a surrogate father, or Alex is not Danielles.

How does everything we know contradict this? Alex's name is still Alex. That means Ben didn't just steal Alex from Danielle. As far as I know, Ben knocked her up. It sure seemed to me that he's the real father and until they say so otherwise, all signs point that way to me.

I also think you are way off here
There is nothing at all that supports that Ben could have knocked her up, if it is pure speculation, then I suppose anything is possible.  You say "it sure seems to me that Ben is the real father" how did you come to that conclusion?  As far as we have seen so far we are not even sure that it is Ben they are referring to when they talk about her father (we are all just assuming at this point).  But if Ben is the one they are referring too I really doubt that he is her biological father.

HAHAHAHA There's nothing that suggests he didn't knock her up either! Get real people.

[daisyrain]

Danielle arrived on the isalnd when she was pregnant, Ben has lived on the island his whole life. Ben is not the biological father he just raised her.

[airdudei]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

[daisyrain]

If he was part of Danielles team why would she hand him over to Sayid when he gets trapped in the net?
I agree he is a liar but I dont think he had anything to do with Danielle getting pregnant

[jugdish]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

But the information came from Danielle not Ben.

[JBRam]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

Danielle said she killed everyone from the team, and then the OTHERs stole Alex.

Ben has Alex.

Ben is one of the others.

Therefore, Ben was not in the science team.

Therefore Ben did not have sex with Danielle and get her pregnant when they were on opposite sides of the globe, literally.

[jugdish]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

Danielle said she killed everyone from the team, and then the OTHERs stole Alex.

Ben has Alex.

Ben is one of the others.

Therefore, Ben was not in the science team.

Therefore Ben did not have sex with Danielle and get her pregnant when they were on opposite sides of the globe, literally.

Perfectly stated!!

[JBRam]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

Danielle said she killed everyone from the team, and then the OTHERs stole Alex.

Ben has Alex.

Ben is one of the others.

Therefore, Ben was not in the science team.

Therefore Ben did not have sex with Danielle and get her pregnant when they were on opposite sides of the globe, literally.

Perfectly stated!!

Thanks Juggy. Does this make up for some of my crappily stated posts?

[jugdish]

It helps

[PrincessLeia]

"crapily stated" rofl 

Yes...that was a good post, JB.  It encapsulates my thoughts as well. 

[JBRam]

"crapily stated" rofl 

Yes...that was a good post, JB.  It encapsulates my thoughts as well. 

Thanks guys!

[Optimus J]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

Danielle said she killed everyone from the team, and then the OTHERs stole Alex.

Ben has Alex.

Ben is one of the others.

Therefore, Ben was not in the science team.

Therefore Ben did not have sex with Danielle and get her pregnant when they were on opposite sides of the globe, literally.

Thinking more deeply it's even ironic that Danielle had the guy who stole her daughter in her hands and handed it to Sayid. Dude, if she knew...

[PrincessLeia]

Bens a liar, he probably crashed with Danielle

Danielle said she killed everyone from the team, and then the OTHERs stole Alex.

Ben has Alex.

Ben is one of the others.

Therefore, Ben was not in the science team.

Therefore Ben did not have sex with Danielle and get her pregnant when they were on opposite sides of the globe, literally.

Thinking more deeply it's even ironic that Danielle had the guy who stole her daughter in her hands and handed it to Sayid. Dude, if she knew...

Good point!  As hard as she has tried to get Alex back??  Yeah....this gives me all the more reason to believe that Ben & Danielle are NOT in cahoots.  lol

Great post.