What's Hot: 6x05: User Requested Images
In 3x22, "Greatest Hits", we see Charlie in his flashback standing on a corner, performing an Oasis song when he is interrupted by a sudden downpour. At first look, it seems this is the same scene from Flashes Before Your Eyes. But if so, where is Desmond? On closer inspection, however, it is evident we are witnessing two separate, but independent events. Charlie's shirt is different, he doesn't appear to have the sign, the surrounding buildings are different (although there is a NewsAgent stand in both, the font is different on the two stands).
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: 3x21: Charlie, Oasis and Rain.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://lost.cubit.net/cgi-bin/mt5/mttb_xyz2.cgi/297
You hear enough of our opinions on this site! We want to know what our users think! Do you have an idea for an article, review, spoiler material, humorous commentary, parody, or other materials regarding LOST or SWLS? We want to publish your articles on SWLS! Just submit your well written and captivating article to us, and if we like what you have to say, we'll publish it!
Can this reinforce the idea that what Desmond sees is NOT fate and can indeed be altered?
it IS naomi
I agree that looks very much like Naomi.
This is pre-Drive Shaft (Charlie has no ring).
Is this before or after Drive Shaft made it big?
Seems like charlie surviving has changed the timeline again. Does the wierd guy standing there ever show up anywhere before? Looks like Naomi in hat, No its not Libby.
gold car of death in the background!
Is it just me but does the blonde girl in the pic talking to the blonde guy look like lagroot?
Did anyone notice that when charlie is learning how to swim... right before he's about to jump in you her someone say "Desmond"???
The girl in the hat does look a bit like Naomi. In the top picture where we can see her from the back, her hair looks quite a bit blonder than Naomi's currently, but of course hair color is easy to change. I think the girl with the umbrella looks a lot like Libby.
Seems like definitely two different scenes in two different places, and I think the Covent Gardens Underground is just where it took place, not intended to be a clue or whatever. It was interesting that the words to the song Charlie was singing went something like "You'll be the one to save me..." -- hint that Desmond will save him?
hello every body.i'm from china.and i
am 14 years old.i love lost very much.
i want to improve my english here.
Completely-ish off topic. Oasis were called Rain before they were called Oasis.
You know, when I watched the Lost: The Answers special today they showed when Smokie was pulling Locke into the ground and I realized that even though we had already seen what Smokie looked like, they never showed him. It got me to thinking on this underground thing. What if somebody was pulling Locke into some underground tunnel or something because they knew he was special?
The one thing that stuck out at me was the UndergrounD. The sign was different than the Covent Garden and it struck me odd. I didn't see anything in the article about underground. Furthermore Charlie wrote on his paper covent garden, which made me more suspicious. If the camera didn't pan to Charlies audience so many times I wouldn't have thought twice, however, I suspected the shots were trying to tell us something. I didnt catch Naomi in the hat, and I still am not sure that is her. However with the hatches being underground and now the looking glass being under water I wondered if it was a foreshadowing of what was to come for Charlie?
Interesting point...did not think of that. So when Locke put the numbers in which was to say there was an incursion by the Hostiles, thats what triggered the signal. But my question would be this...how does she know about Penny and Desmond?
I think Naomi is a Dharma caracter, that came to the island to inspect the sos hostiles that locke imputed on the flame computer, that's why patchy was so concerned on saving her and telling Ben about her... She got to the island and can get out (or not)
I don't see how Naomi is an other...Mikhail wouldn't have told Ben about it like it was news and you could see Ben freaked when he heard. Again, thats part of the reason why they're rushing to get the Losties, esp w/the satellite phone...but I totally agree, that is Sayid's girl...it was what I thought right away (and I thought it was Charlie's bro trying to steal the purse actually)
First, Firelog, obviously it does look like Naomi otherwise people wouldnt be commenting on it. I too thought it looked like her but I had previously been misled slightly by an eyewitness who watched them film the scene who said that the girl who played Naomi was on set.
Secondly, mcmorri, the girl in the alleyway was indeed Sayid's girlfriend Nadia. Seems like she is connected to quite a few of the castaways. I can see some major storylines in the future for Nadia.
Also Henry Gale (crash) landed on the island in a hot air balloon rather than a parachute.
Finally, Nancy Drew, Covent Garden is a London Underground station on the Piccadilly line. I think its just a random set location to show the viewers that Charlie is busking in London, Covent Garden is well known for street performers.
LINK: Clickie
Did you notice in "Greatest Hits", Charlie's t-shirt has a skeleton on it? Just wardrobe or intentional?
Has anyone found any reference to the Covent Underground Garden? I saw it last night and was wondering if it was an easter egg, of sorts. Are we to think that there is also an underground thing going on as well as an under water thing on the island?
was the girl in the ally Sayid's girlfriend? I think Naomi is an other, "Henry Gale" also landed on the island by parachute! Perhaps the ship she speaks of is actually the underwater station?
Not sure how reliable it is, but Wikipedia's trivia for this episode counts Naomi among the people on the street watching Charlie play. I thought I saw here there last night, too. Either way - glad they let Charlie stick around a while - I like his character and story line.
NO WAY is the girl in the hat Naomi, looks nothing like her
It is also a different time of the year. people are dressed for cooler weather.
I thought the same thing about the Lady with the Hat Looking like Naomi.. Naomi did say that she heard of Him and His group.. Could it be???
I don't think that's Naomi but are the others in the 3rd picture Others? The woman with the umbrella & the guy? Or does she look like Libby? I don't know but they seem familiar...
this girl with the hat looks really much like Naomi. i was thinking that also while watching the episode
Also, in Greatest Hits Carlie is wearing a ring on his right ring finger and his left pointer finger whereas he is not wearing any rings in Flashes Before Your Eyes.
is that Naomi in the black hat watching him play???
oops///
second last pic...
a sign in the background of the last pic says 'UNDERCROUND' is it meant to be like that or 'UNDERGROUND'??