Quote from: YtsejammerHi, I´m new to this forum, but I've been a Lost fan since ep1I don´t believe Fenry caused the lockdown...  my theory is that Fenry made everything up...  he could have had Russeau catch him, so he knew they would take him to the hatch, discover he was an other, and then pushed the button and lied to Locke to confuse him, so Lock would think everything was fake and ultimately blow up the Swan station, and make Michael bring Jack, Kate, Hurley and Sawyer to make sure they weren't on the hatch when it blowed up.Why do you think he told Locke he was suposed to take him to the others to win his trust, but didn´t ordered to include him on the list the others gave to Michael?Fenry was almost shot, tortured to death, strangled, beaten to death, etc.  He took a huge risk if he "knew everything."  Barring him knowing the future, if he even knew anything about 851's history with the others he would know that they kill others for a living.  I don't think this is very probable.

Quote from: BobBX542Richie-look around on other sites, you will see all sorts of twin/clone thoeries that have popped up since bad twin was released. Also, my assumption on the name comes from the people I know in the military. The way some of these guys are, you don't want to be "Kelvin the CIA operative", You want to be "JOE, THE CIA OPERATIVE" you know?? To put it another way, if two guys were fighting, and they were named Joe and Kelvin, I would put my money on Joe. This is not to say that he just called him self Joe, it could have been a middle name or something really simple, and when you're on an island, and you only have one person to talk to, maybe he wanted him to use his real name because it's his real name.I am pretty sure in the last officral ABC Lost Podcast they said his  real full name was Kelvin Joe Inman.  So yes it was a middle name, and what you say sounds logical.

Quote from: sledgewebOK, but remember, Joe Inman and Sam Austen were in the same episode together... I don't know why anyone thinks they are the same guy...Sam Austen: http://lost.cubit.net/images/profile/SamAusten.jpgJoe/Kelvin Inman: http://lost.cubit.net/images/profile/JoeInman.jpgThanks Sledge, anyway we can have a scren cap of the quarantine door as eko sees itand the one at the very end of the finale?

Quote from: richieI agree most of it is out there. But everyone elses possible doubles have at least had similar names to shut down the separte people theory.Why would Joe/Kelvin, if they are one person, change their first name and not their surname...? That doesn't make any sense. The only thing to me that suggests they are in fact the same person is that Kelvin "ran an army", which Joe did. Mind you, that is concrete evidence they are the same, I realize.Cia operatives lie a lot to get what they need...just like the others.  I'm not saying they're related but I put about as much stock in what Kelvin says as what Fenry said.

Um, I just want to know why we are assuming Joe and Kelvin are the same person and not (Bad?) Twins???

OK, but remember, Joe Inman and Sam Austen were in the same episode together... I don't know why anyone thinks they are the same guy...Sam Austen: http://lost.cubit.net/images/profile/SamAusten.jpgJoe/Kelvin Inman: http://lost.cubit.net/images/profile/JoeInman.jpg

Sledge can we have a screen cap of kelvin the guy training Sayid (yes know it's kelvin)and Kate's dad either in truck with sayid or when she goes into his office after she kills her stepdad?

IF there ever was a Radzinsky, I doubt that Inman bumped him off. The position of the blood stain was about right for a shotgun to the mouth, which is most likely to be self inflicted.

The faked death of Inman is possible. Lots of other things he said were also false after all.

Quote from: BonesOkay speculation but Kelvin died pretty easily.  Faked death?  Is it even possible?I thought the same thing, Bones.  I mean, it sounded like his head cracked open, but it did seem pretty easy.  Of course, the boat was still there when Des ran away, if Kelvin didn't die, I suspect he would have taken the boat.... but I still think a faked death is a possibility.

Quote from: alwayslostWith Inmans background I wonder how the bloodspot of Radzinsky really got on the ceiling?  Maybe Inman let the clock wind down and pull Desmond's boat in...sorry, lots of speculation here.  these are 2 things i was wondering too. 

Quote from: deebeeIsn't he also the man Kate thought to be her father?He was the cia agent who taught sayid how to torture  in irag

Okay speculation but Kelvin died pretty easily.  Faked death?  Is it even possible?

Yes he scared Desmont so he wont notice him fixing the boat if he saw him he would understand he is going to escape and game over he will be in a thight situation if he kills des and runs away-the world ends if he does not he has to stay and keep pushing the button and Des leaves with the boat etc.

My impression was that he did this to keep des in the hatch and then he could go running around as long as he wanted. He then had to keep it up while he fixed the boat.

Well, the Gulf War was in 91, so, he would have left the CIA and joined Dharma sometime during or after 1991. We don't know how long he has been on the island, but, sometime between 1991 and 2001.

Anyone have the timeline figured out for "Kelvin". He had to be on the island for at least 3 years since we know desmond was. How does this fit in with his time with syiad